Hello everybody, thank you so much for joining Straight Talk, I am so excited for this episode. I'm also nervous, I got to admit. I am here with rock stars, we already have met Jamie Harrison with Capital Markets. You've been in this episode before.
Jamie:
I have. Yeah, I'm a veteran.
Jenine:
But now we have the rock star of market makers.
Jamie:
That's right.
Jenine:
Does that exist? Do people know that? It's like the Taylor Swift of it. So, Katie Stiner with Citadel, but let's be clear, Citadel Securities.
Katie:
Securities. Yes.
Jenine:
So, Katie, can you tell us just really quickly who's Citadel Securities?
Katie:
Sure. Citadel Securities is the largest retail market maker in the United States, we have a 35%+ share of retail flow. In that capacity, we trade all US equities, including all US listed ETFs, which is why I'm delighted to be here today with you.
Jenine:
And what's your role at the company?
Katie:
I am the co-head of ETF issuer services. So, I manage all of the relationships with ETF issuers that bring products to market, and try to help them bring products to market that are likely to succeed and trade well.
Jenine:
So, the reason I talk about rock stars, this relationship's really important to us, but in particular you.
Jamie:
Yes.
Jenine:
So, Jamie, talk about again what you do for MFS.
Jamie:
Sure thing. So, at MFS, I manage ETF capital markets, and that means I coordinate our internal investment teams and our external liquidity providers, and I'm very lucky to be able to coordinate those relationships with premier liquidity providers, like Katie Stiner. Katie and I have been working together for over 10 years at this point, we've seen a lot happen within the industry, and partnerships like Katie and I have increasingly important as the space continues to be saturated with new product, specifically on the active side.
Jenine:
So, a lot has been happening. So, this is actually why we're here today to educate. So, you said about a lot of ETFs coming out.
Jamie:
Yes. Yeah. So, we are absolutely living in a transformative period, a generationally transformative period in terms of the asset management industry, and the transition into ETFs, specifically active ETFs. And as you see here in 2019 with the passing of the ETF rule, rule 6c-11, the SEC, that was a rule that the SEC passed that codified listing standards and made it much more efficient for managers to come to market launching an ETF. As a result, we've seen a steady increase in the amount of launches per year, and here we are in 2026, and this number is now well over 1000 ETFs have been launched this year. So, there's an incredible amount of product coming to market and it's becoming increasingly important to lean into those partnerships, lean into those liquidity providers, to make sure that we're bringing a product to market that's not only optimized for the vehicle, but has the adequate support from market makers and from banks in order to facilitate ease of trading, ease of access, tax efficiency, all of these things take partnerships in the street, and certainly Katie's been a huge help in that regard.
Jenine:
Okay. So, ETFs launched, but not all ETFs successfully launched.
Jamie:
That's right. Which brings us to our next slide, ETF delistings by calendar year. So, over 1000 ETFs launched this year, but we're also seeing an increasing amount of ETF closures. The average lifespan of a closed ETF was four years, it's now two years, and as you can see, over 160 ETFs have been closed this year. So, what's the difference? What makes the difference between an ETF that's scalable, that has a commercial lifespan, and what's the difference between an ETF that doesn't? And really what that comes down to is first you need a compelling product first and foremost, but you also need an accessible product. You need a commercial product. What does that mean? That means you need to have tight spreads, ease of trading, ease of access, the product needs to maintain its tax efficiency... All of these things are essential if you want to scale the product and you want to distribute it.
Jenine:
So, basically these that delisted did not meet those expectations.
Jamie:
That's right. I mean, you'd see dislocation from NAV, poor trading, clients having an issue accessing a product, clients having an issue exiting a product, and certainly that's even a bigger problem when volatility hits in times of market disruption. So, I'd say not being able to scale the product is the number one reason why you're seeing an increasing amount of closures, a lot of that comes around not having a commercial product, not being able to provide ease of access to your clients.
Jenine:
Okay. And so, Katie, this could be alarming to see, is it?
Katie:
I'm not alarmed by the amount of closures, I think it's very healthy for the ecosystem to take stock of what's working and what's not, and for people to feel confident innovating, failing, and then trying again with new product. I don't see any issue with it. And we as market makers think it's very healthy for products to go through cycles. Not every product will be a roaring success and that's okay, that's one of the reasons that the ETF wrapper is so compelling is that it's pretty easy to bring product to market. It's not easy to stay. And that comes down to a lot of factors, most notably all of the decisions made by the ETF issuer.
Jenine:
Okay. So, let's talk about that because I know you find that healthy and that's wonderful, I would like ours to launch successfully.
Jamie:
Of course.
Jenine:
So, what do we look at to make sure, because we have how many so far?
Jamie:
13 ETFs.
Jenine:
In what timeframe? When did we-
Jamie:
Less than two years.
Jenine:
Less than two years, and we're going to continue to launch.
Jamie:
Yep. We're going to continue to launch, we're going to continue to lean into our strengths. Excited-
Jenine:
And so, how do we make sure that we are on the launch, not the delist?
Jamie:
So, I think Katie's right, it is important to have products that aren't going to scale, not every product's going to be successful. It's healthy for the market for those products to eventually delist. For us at MFS, I think it's increasingly important that we explain to our clients our approach to the business. And for us, it's less about the vehicle, it's more about the client and what their outcomes and objectives are. And certainly launch of our ETFs don't represent a new business line, we're leaning into our strengths, our current capabilities, offering it in a vehicle that offers specific benefits to specific clients, mainly tax efficiency, transparency, and the flexibility that comes with the tradeability of the product. And I think clients are focused on this delisting number, and it can be a black eye, to be candid.
If you put your clients, if an advisor puts client money into a vehicle that eventually delists, that's not a great thing, and that's likely a taxable event as well for the client. So, we're seeing more attention being paid to issuer due diligence. What's your approach to the product? What kind of resources are you bringing to bear? What's your commitment to the franchise? And what do your partnerships look like?
Jenine:
So, here's what I find really interesting because this relationship is fairly new for investors to understand, capital markets and market makers. And from what we talked about while we were getting makeup... This is not natural if you were not aware. That you guys chose each other, and I know that sounds bizarre. And you were just married, and so we're not talking about that type of a relationship. But the fact is, when we launched, you went out and absolutely said, "We want Katie and Citadel." And you said, "We will accept." And that does not happen all the time.
Katie:
We want to work with MFS, not just accept, we want to work.
Jenine:
So, tell me a little bit about how the behind the scenes worked because I didn't think that was a thing.
Katie:
Sure. Yeah. I think that for many investors, it's very hard to understand the relationship between a market maker and ETF issuer, because usually it's being disintermediated by the platform through which they trade. Maybe they're trading through a retail custodian or a TAM, and as a result, they're not really familiar with who is provisioning the liquidity on the other side. But when a new ETF launches, it needs a lot of help. Because ETFs, unlike a standard common stock, don't go through a book building process, there isn't a road show like with an IPO to sell an ETF. ETFs come to market, and one day they're not there, and the next day they exist, and someone has to manage the spread around that to ensure that the spread accurately reflects the fair value of the underlyings, even if there's no volume. And that's the role of a lead market maker.
And so, when you pick a lead market maker, it's an act of trust, it's a relationship. So, Citadel tries very hard to partner with people with whom we have high depth of relationship. So, things in the ETF trading world don't usually go great, but sometimes things go wrong, and you do need a depth of relationship, you need someone to lean on when you have a challenging trading situation, and similarly, we need to know that our partner is reliable, that they're providing us with accurate information about the nature of their product, and that they're actively trying to design a product that is both good for their investors and also good for the ETF ecosystem, and that includes trading.
Jenine:
So, something did actually recently happen yesterday, you were talking about that relationship. Can you bring that to life?
Katie:
Absolutely. So, in addition to being MFS's lead market maker for several of their products, we are also their designated market maker on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. And in that capacity, we have a specialist who sits on the floor, or stands on the floor rather, and he monitors the auctions. MFS opted into this particular protocol because they felt that their investors were more likely than average to utilize auction liquidity in ETFs, which is a somewhat unusual thing. But the good thing about MFS is that they knew their investors, and as a result, they partnered with someone who could be helpful and could actively support those investors' needs.
So, yesterday on the close in one of your products, there was an exceptionally large closing auction, and that auction could have been quite disruptive because if there's not adequate size on the other side of the trade, you'll see a dislocation right at the close, which is a really bad outcome for a lot of clients because from their perspective, there shouldn't be any difference in the liquidity provision intraday versus in the auction. Our specialist stepped in, took the other side of the trade and transferred that risk to our ETF market making desk. All of MFS's clients involved were well protected and there was no deviation versus NAV. And that's a great outcome for everyone and we were really happy to assist.
Jamie:
I think that floor listing really speaks to MFS' approach to our ETF franchise, which is a focus on client outcomes and client experiences. And in a situation last night when I know that we've done our job is when the client is unaware of the efforts that we've put in. And certainly Katie mentioned, there was a large amount of interest that came into one of our ETFs on the close, we love to see it, we love to see buying activity. And the ETF closed very tight to its underlying NAV, and I'm sure the client was unaware that anything additional had happened behind the scenes. But what had happened behind the scenes is we had a human element that was able to step into the auction, pause the auction, slow things down and meet that client with liquidity at a price that's very tight to the products underlying NAV.
The ETF didn't close at 4:00, it closed at 4:08 PM, but there's no dislocation to NAV. We've got a smooth chart, product acted as intended, and our other clients aren't burdened by a dislocation on their chart in terms of their performance. So, we know we're doing our job when the client has that ease of access, when they don't know anything has gone on, when there's no disruption to their daily business, and that's really important to us at MFS.
Jenine:
So, that is wild. So, that's rare, is what you're saying, but happens. And so, to be able to have someone... I didn't realize you can say stop, don't close and wait.
Jamie:
Well, not all ETFs can, and I think that's important distinction. So, a couple of years ago, the NYSE opened up the NYSE floor model for ETFs.
Jenine:
The NYSE?
Jamie:
The New York Stock Exchange. Thanks Jenine.
Jenine:
See, the lingo.
Jamie:
That's right. And so, historically that option was only available to your large companies, your ExxonMobils, your Disneys, your common equity, your common stock. When the NYSE opened this up to ETFs, it was because of this auction issue, where there can be immense amount of liquidity or liquidity demands that are needed around the auction, and for issuers who wanted that human element. To be able to step in, meet that liquidity at a price tight to the underlying NAV. Now, 99% of ETFs are listed electronically, and they'll close at 4:00 irregardless of conscious side interest. And that's fine most of the time.
Jenine:
Say that again, what percent electronically?
Jamie:
I would say 99% of ETFs.
Jenine:
Wow.
Jamie:
So, there's less than 100 ETFs listed on the floor of the stock exchange, it's a much more expensive listing option. But again, MFS approached this market, right? Client-focus behind everything we do, and that's just another symptom of it.
Jenine:
That's great. That's great. So, let's talk about the unexpected and things to be thinking about, and you mentioned liquidity, the markets get volatile. How does that all work?
Katie:
Yeah. I think the volatile markets are a part of every type of trading, not just ETFs. As with any other listing, ETFs will widen in volatile conditions, that is normal because a market maker would not want to be overly exposed on each tick if the market is moving really aggressively in one direction. Because every time that we post liquidity on screen, we are essentially offering ourselves up to the market, and the market gets to react to that. I will say, ETFs, what you're looking for in an ETF is you're looking for both spread and depth. One of the biggest challenges that I think a lot of investors face is that they are trying to get a trade done, and they might have a lot of constraints on how they trade. Many of the end user clients and investors in ETFs are very constrained in terms of how they can route, how they can trade, the different options they have.
And that's why it's really important to talk to ETF capital markets teams for any ETF issuer that you interact with, because they can guide you in terms of how you can transact without having excess volatility in the price. There's a lot of different options, and they also communicate very actively with market makers. We get calls that say, "Our client is exceptionally constrained in their execution options, can you please be supportive of their needs on screen?" That's a call that we take, and we absolutely attempt to stand there and provide liquidity at a price that is commensurate and reasonable with regard to the fair value or NAV in all conditions. But yes, in volatile markets, it's harder. Things are moving, depth can shrink, and spreads will widen. So, if you have any flexibility at all, be communicative because that will help overcome some of the challenges associated with volatile markets.
Jenine:
Which is why-
Katie:
Jamie exists.
Jenine:
Jamie and team is our rock star at MFS with the capital markets.
Katie:
Yes.
Jenine:
Anything you want to add to that?
Jamie:
Yeah, I think it's really important. And I think there's a lot of attention on trading and liquidity spreads, market depth, and the reason for that is because a lot of our advisors that are coming into the active ETF space are legacy mutual fund holders. And in a mutual fund, you subscribe or you redeem at the close of NAV, and you're not avoiding any of those costs that are exhibited in ETF spread, it's just embedded in the underlying NAV. So, there's a lot of focus when you pull an ETF up on screen for the first time of what is this spread? What does it mean? Does it represent my transaction cost? Why is a bigger spread... Why is a wider spread worse than a tighter spread and what goes into that spread? And so, we spend a lot of time educating our advisors on what that means, how it translates to their ultimate return, how it ultimately translates to their transaction costs and what we're doing at MFS to control those.
And a lot of that is by having a robust capital market team, by partnering with premier liquidity providers like Citadel. And I think we'd spend a lot of time on that education, and I'd advise any viewers to check out our website because we have a lot of materials on there. But a lot of our advice is around the trading. I know I've done my job if I speak to a client and I'm off the phone in five minutes and I don't hear from them again. Because these are really, you can retain this information and it's really not rocket science. If it's a small order, using a limit which provides price protection, placing that limit near the offer when buying or near the bid when selling, or leveraging your platform trading desk for block trades. Something that we've both seen coming through this industry is a massive...
The ability of these platform trading desks to understand how to trade these ETFs, how to access liquidity, and how to achieve best executions for their clients has come a very long, long way, and we have a lot of trust in our intermediary platform custodial desks. So, we advise our advisors, if they're going to put on a large execution, leverage that platform trading desk. They're going to get in touch with me, they're going to get in touch with Katie, they're going to get best execution. Also, we talked about volatile markets, spreads widen out during volatile periods. So, avoid those volatile periods if you can. If there's Fed speak, if there's a rate decision, if there's breaking economic years, if timing isn't a constraint, wait for calmer seas.
Usually that can take 15 minutes, a half an hour, it's not a long period of time. But engaging with an issuer's capital market team, engaging with the street, we can connect you with platform custodial desks, that's a service that we can provide. We want to be a resource for our advisors, whether it's our ETFs or others. Because we hate to see bad experiences which can eat into return and cause a bad trade.
Jenine:
So, what is the biggest misconception that you've heard and seen as we continue to learn and experience that you see?
Katie:
I think that the biggest challenge that we see oftentimes is that a lot of investors are treating ETFs like single stocks. Anytime you treat an ETF like a single stock, you're oftentimes disadvantaging yourself. Single stocks, when you look at the onscreen depth, that's a pretty good representation of appetite. Whereas, in the ETF space, onscreen depth is only a fraction of the appetite that you might get if you go to your custodial block desk and ask them to put your ETF order in competition, in some sort of request for quote RFQ format. ETFs, because ETFs are arbitrageable instruments, meaning that someone could be out there looking at the basket of the ETF versus the price of the ETF, and arbitraging that difference, incentives are very different from market makers in terms of displaying liquidity as compared to single stocks. Another sort of mistake that we see made in that same framing is that a lot of people think that there's tremendous liquidity in ETFs around the close.
That's a very single stock phenomenon, it does not exist in ETFs because the ETF primary mechanism, that's the means by which we create and redeem, is shut down after the market closes. So, trading before the market closes is a great idea, in fact, I tell people the best time of day to trade almost all ETFs is 10:15 Eastern time because by then price discovery has happened in the underlyings, European markets are still open. You've got plenty of time on the clock to submit primary activity in a fixed income ETF, if there's a cutoff time. So, in the absence of any other information, and of course being mindful of data and all sorts of other things that are more episodic, getting stuff done mid-morning is a fabulous time to trade an ETF.
Jenine:
Wow.
Jamie:
I think Katie hit the nail on the head there. We hear a lot of times, especially newly launched ETFs, screen liquidity, simply the amount of shares that an ETF trades on a daily basis, and that doesn't equate to liquidity for an ETF. And the simple reason is it's not a stock, right? There's an open-ended amount of shares that can be created to meet demand. So, when you're trading IBM or Disney, there's a finite amount of shares. So, if you have a large amount of supply to either buy or sell, you can reasonably extrapolate that you're going to have impact on the price of that name. For an ETF, because it's open-ended, market makers like Katie are able to create shares to meet that demand. So, onscreen volume doesn't equate to liquidity, what equates to liquidity is the liquidity of the underlying basket of securities that the ETF holds.
And we spend a lot of time engaging with the street, engaging with people like Katie to make sure that we're optimizing our ETFs from a liquidity standpoint, to make sure that we're balancing our alpha generation with our spread impact, and making sure that we're controlling the costs for our market makers to acquire that underlying basket of securities so that they can provide immense amount of liquidity to our clients. And again, we know we've done our job when a client can put on a simple limit order and execute block trades or leverage their platform trading desk or trade around the close and not have any of these dislocations or bad experiences that we hear around from others in the industry.
And this podcast... Or I'm sorry, our Straight Talk is titled, An Arms Race, and you saw the chart, over 1000 ETFs are launched this year. So, I think it's increasingly important that our advisors and our clients and investors engage with an issuer and see what their approach is. Are they thinking about tradeability? Are they thinking about accessibility, and who are they partnering with to protect me when I go to put that trade on?
Jenine:
I think it's a great point because as your slide showed, it was 2019... You quoted some IRS, what did you quote?
Jamie:
2019. Yeah. Floodgates open for active ETFs. The ETF rule as we'll call it, from the SEC, was passed.
Jenine:
Okay.
Jamie:
Codifying listing standards made it much easier to come to market.
Jenine:
See, all this talk. What was the number? You threw out the number as if that was common-
Katie:
6c-11.
Jamie:
We geek out on ETFs. Yeah, rule 6c-11.
Jenine:
Okay. So, if anyone wants to learn more, there you go. So, you brought up liquidity, we have a piece in the console to walk people through examples, right? We also have a piece called, Four Questions to Ask. Why was that important for us to...
Jamie:
Yeah. I think it's really important. Again, we want to be a resource for our clients outside of just their own ETFs, and we want to make sure that when they engage with an issuer, when there is an allocator discussion, that they're thinking about who they're partnering with in the right ways. And to put it candidly, not all ETFs are created equal, not all issuers are created equal, there are issuers today, we are seeing some bubbly stuff in the industry, trying to capture short-term trends, trying to be first to market, and there are unintended consequences to strategies like that.
So, this piece that we've released on our website really walks you through the four questions that you should ask your advisors that we think will shed a lot of light in terms of their approach to the business, their focus on their clients, and if they're here to capture a short-term trend or if they're here to build a durable franchise.
Jenine:
That's great.
Jamie:
Yeah.
Jenine:
That's great. And then, we also have a quarterly ETF Pulse that your team produces if people want to subscribe to.
Jamie:
That's right, ETF Pulse, subscribe to it. We know everybody's busy, it takes about two minutes to read. It gives you a quarterly snapshot of what's going on in the business, where flows are heading, and any hot topics that we think our clients should be aware about.
Jenine:
That's great. So, the bottom line for me is you don't need to know everything, you just need to surround yourself with people who know everything. So, I am thrilled you took the time to be here.
Katie:
Thank you so much for having me.
Jenine:
Is there any last thought, knowing that you really are the behind the scenes of rock stars that people should be aware?
Katie:
You're very kind, Jenine. I think what everyone watching this should hope is that they never meet me. They never need to know me because if ,you are dealing with high caliber ETF issuers, if you're talking to high caliber ETF capital markets teams and distribution folks, you will never have to interact with Citadel Securities, and we can live behind the curtain and support your liquidity as needed. Diligencing your ETF issuer is really important, I think the Four Questions piece is a fantastic idea, and we're always telling people to know your issuer. Know their strengths, know their relationships, and I think you guys really covered everything that I would wish for many RIAs and end user investors to know. But we're really honored to be here and delighted to be providing liquidity for MFS ETFs.
Jenine:
Katie, Jamie, thank you once again. Jamie, I think you're going to be a repeater, and Katie, I have a feeling that people are going to get to know you because we might have to ask you to come back.
Katie:
It would be my pleasure. Thank you.
Jenine:
Awesome. Thank you everybody. Make sure you take advantage of the pieces in the console, and we appreciate your support and your partnership. Thank you very much.
The views expressed in this presentation are those of the presenter. These views should not be relied upon as investment advice, as securities recommendations, or as an indication of trading intent on behalf of any other MFS investment product. MFS does not provide legal, tax, or accounting advice. Clients of MFS should obtain their own independent tax and legal advice based on their particular circumstances.
Past performance is no guarantee of future results. No forecasts can be guaranteed.
Unless otherwise indicated, logos and product and service names are trademarks of MFS® and its affiliates and may be registered in certain countries.
Distributed by: U.S. - MFS Investment Management and MFS Fund Distributors, Inc., Member SIPC; Latin America - MFS International Ltd.
Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) trade like stocks, are subject to investment risk, and will fluctuate in market value. Shares of ETFs are bought and sold at market price, not NAV, and are not individually redeemed from the fund. The market price at the time of sale may be higher or lower than the fund’s NAV, and any applicable brokerage commissions will reduce returns. There can be no guarantee that an active market for the funds will develop or be maintained.
Actively managed ETFs differ from traditional ETFs in that they do not seek to replicate or to track a specific index. As such, the ability of an actively managed ETF to achieve its objective will depend on the effectiveness of the fund’s portfolio manager.
The fund may not achieve its objective and/or you could lose money on your investment in the fund.
69579.1