Investment Insights

Don't Make Yield a Matter of Principal: Consider Total Return

Consider a balanced focus on total return within a fixed income portfolio.

In Brief

  • Income investors may be taking more risk — interest rate, credit and liquidity risk — to meet their cash flow needs as they stretch for yield in a low-rate environment.

  • As bond price sensitivity to interest rates (duration risk) has increased, the incremental yield available to investors who take on this added risk has decreased.

  • A balanced focus on total return within a fixed income portfolio could offer the potential for income, lower volatility and, where appropriate, some capital appreciation.

Key risks in fixed income

Interest rate risk — The risk that interest rates will rise, making today’s bonds less valuable

Credit risk — The risk that a bond could be downgraded or that principal will not be repaid

Liquidity risk — The risk that there will be too few interested buyers when you want to sell the bond

With bond yields near record lows, investors who rely on portfolio income to help fund their living expenses are struggling to generate income without excessive risk to their principal. And yet, in their stretch for yield, these investors may be doing just what they hope to avoid — taking on more risk.

While fixed income assets are usually intended to be the lower-risk component of a portfolio, they do have certain risks — interest rate, credit and liquidity risk — that could catch investors off guard. For investors who want to generate returns to support their cash flow needs while remaining mindful of these risks, a total-return-focused fixed income approach that pursues yield and the potential for capital appreciation might be worth considering.

In addition to income, a total return approach might invest in a broader array of fixed income asset classes to seek capital appreciation where appropriate. For investors, such an approach might offer additional sources of return and the possibility of managing some of the risks encountered in the quest for yield alone

Income remains elusive

Bond yields are certainly a key determinant of total return; however, we believe the returns we have seen in the past won’t be replicated in the future, so generating alpha becomes more critical. Yields have been on the decline since the 1980s, as shown in Exhibit 1. Even after the US Federal Reserve raised short-term rates in late 2015, for the first time since 2006, the 10-year Treasury yield continued to hover around 2%. Meanwhile, yields on high-quality corporate bonds and municipal debt have been similarly meager.

With high-quality bonds paying so little in the way of yield, investors have often responded by taking more risk (e.g., buying lower-quality bonds for their potentially higher yields) in order to achieve a return that meets their income needs. But it really hasn’t been worth their while because the incremental yield received when taking more risk has actually decreased. Duration risk measures the sensitivity of a bond’s price to a change in interest rates. (As most investors realize, when interest rates go up, bond prices go down.) The higher a bond’s duration, the greater its sensitivity to rising interest rates. As Exhibit 2 shows, as interest rate risk has risen, yields have fallen.

A total return approach to fixed income

In an environment where the ability to earn income has changed but the expenses that require income have not, investors may want to consider a total return approach to fixed income rather than only seeking yield. In fixed income, a total return focus means recognizing all components of return that might be available to investors. That means understanding and accounting for the important role principal plays in the equation.

When investors engage in income- or yield-seeking behavior, they don’t always consider the related impact on their principal. Often, as we discussed, they end up adding too much risk to their portfolio. Investment managers taking a total return approach to fixed income consider the impact on principal as well as the ability to generate income. As market cycles, credit cycles and business cycles change, we think it is critical to try to manage downside risks in order to deliver strong risk-adjusted performance streams. At other points in these cycles, investment managers might also look for capital appreciation opportunities, where they believe they might add value. Certainly yield is an important part of total return; however, we believe investment decisions made with respect to yield should try to avoid subjecting investors to unnecessary risk while seeking to enhance total return.

Put diversification in the mix

A key to managing the risks in fixed income investing, and potentially enhancing a total return approach, is diversification. Investors intuitively understand that putting all their eggs in one basket is too risky, while more broadly diversifying a fixed income portfolio could help reduce its risk profile.

Today, there are more opportunities to diversify in fixed income than there were a few decades ago. In the 1970s, bonds were mostly issued in the United States and in the US dollar. Since then, bond markets have grown significantly around the globe — across regions, in currency denominations and in credit quality. In fact, the market capitalization for debt markets reached over $100 trillion globally at year-end 2016 — an expansion of 3.5 times in just two decades.1

A bond portfolio that includes a range of fixed income exposures can reduce volatility and create more growth opportunities, thus potentially improving total return. In Exhibit 3, a diversified strategy (see dark gray boxes) provided less up-and-down movement than any of the single market segments during the 10-year period ended 31 December 2016. However, it is important to note that diversification per se does not guarantee a profit or protect against a loss.

Managing risks

A total return approach to fixed income investing demands a comprehensive understanding of the risks and opportunities across bond market sectors. We believe active risk management, as it relates to fixed income, is not about the alleviation of risk, but rather the alignment of risk around a manager’s core competencies. It’s a matter of doing the research to try to take the types of risks that the manager believes will be adequately rewarded.

Broad market and individual-issuer risk changes over the course of a market cycle. While bond investors hope to receive all their principal at maturity, the return of principal is never guaranteed, and defaults sometimes occur. In addition, inflation can erode the purchasing power of principal over time. All in all, principal is at risk in varying degrees in any investment, including fixed income.

In a total return approach, we believe the key to managing risk is to exploit the entire fixed income toolkit. That demands a multidisciplinary approach that addresses multiple investor challenges by seeking to balance credit risk and interest risk through intensive research and active risk management, with a goal of enhancing total return.

Reconsidering investment objectives

A decade ago, fixed income investors had the double benefit of low inflation and attractive bond yields — the 10-year US Treasury yield was almost triple the levels of today. But times change, and thoughtful investors change with them. Investors who seek income from their portfolios but don’t want the added risk that comes with stretching for yield, or who want the potential for some capital appreciation, may benefit from reframing their investment objective to pursue total return. Total return investing permits a wider investment view. It allows the diversification of a fixed income portfolio to potentially generate alpha in addition to bond income and aims to improve the overall risk-adjusted return. 

Bonds, if held to maturity, provide a fixed rate of return and a fixed principal value. Bond funds will fluctuate and, when redeemed, may be worth more or less than their original cost.

©2017 Citigroup Index LLC. All rights reserved.

Information has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable but J.P. Morgan does not warrant its completeness or accuracy. The Index is used with permission. The Index may not be copied, used, or distributed without J.P. Morgan’s prior written approval. Copyright 2014, J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved.

The views expressed are those of the author(s) and are subject to change at any time. These views are for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a recommendation to purchase any security or as a solicitation or investment advice from the Advisor. Unless otherwise indicated, logos and product and service names are trademarks of MFS® and its affiliates and may be registered in certain countries.

This content is directed at investment professionals only.

close video

This website uses cookies to operate the site, for site analytics, and for advertising. Please see our Cookies Policy for details and instructions on how you may disable or opt out of cookies. By continuing to use this website you agree to the use of cookies on this site unless you have disabled them.